24 Comments

  1. AS COMCAL AS THIS SONG MAY BE, I THINK CURLY SHOULD HAVE CONVINCED JUD TO DO SOME SOUL-SEARCHING INSTEAD OF CONVINCING HIM TO KILL HIMSELF

  2. Lol this song is so funny yet so depressing. It has a beautiful tone but such saddening subject matter. I like it but only because I don’t think the cowboy was all TOO serious but still….

  3. Can someone please explain this cause I never understood this. How’re you gonna just waltz into someone’s smoke shack, tell them just to kill themself and sing a song about it; all over a girl. I guess it’s supposed to be foreshadowing but it makes Curly look like a diiiick

  4. i love this song, i love what the violins do when he says poor jud is dead, i love the way they change key. beautiful.

  5. I’m in the pit for Oklahoma at my school right now. I love how this song sounds just from the pit. It sounds prettier than you can hear…

  6. It’s interesting that this song is about all the GOOD reasons for Jud to commit suicide. I wonder how you’d feel if someone sang to you about how great it would be for everyone if you killed yourself…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*